Chat

You09:49 AM
I'm looking for 5-10 of the best board wipes for red or black. Preferably they will be low cost to handle early aggro or cheap tribal, and will also have some use or option beyond just the board wipe so it doesn't get stuck in my hand if i don't need it.
ManaDork09:50 AM
Best Pioneer board wipes in red and/or black
You’re asking for interaction pieces, not a full deck — so here’s a short ranked list of Pioneer-legal (R) Red/(B) Black sweepers that hit early tribal/aggro and still do something when the board is empty or you don’t want to wipe yourself.
Tier 1 — best “never dead” / flexible packages
- Brotherhood's End (`{1}{R}{R}`) — Choose 3 to each creature and planeswalker or destroy all artifacts with mana value 3 or less. Best pure modal sweeper in red for Pioneer: clears go-wide boards *and* has a real mode vs The One Ring, treasure piles, and cheap mana rocks. - Extinction Event (`{3}{B}`) — Odd/even exile wipe. Often one-sided if your curve is mostly the other parity; exile stops recursion. Slightly higher CMC, but the “choose the side that hurts them” flexibility is exactly what you asked for. - Sweltering Suns (`{1}{R}{R}`) — 3 to each creature plus cycling `{3}`. If you don’t need the wipe, cycle it. Clean answer to “stuck in hand.” - Gruesome Realization (`{1}{B}{B}`) — Modal: draw two (pay 2) or opponents’ creatures get -1/-1. Partial wipe vs tokens/X/1s *or* pure card advantage. Excellent midrange flex slot. - Slagstorm (`{1}{R}{R}`) — 3 to each creature or 3 to each player. When you don’t need the board clear, it becomes reach/finisher. Great “burn that can also wipe.”
Brotherhood's End
The One Ring
Extinction Event
Sweltering Suns
Gruesome Realization
Slagstorm
Tier 2 — low cost, strong vs early aggro/tribal
- Anger of the Gods (`{1}{R}{R}`) — 3 and exile instead of dying. The gold standard vs Collected Company lines, phoenixes, and anything that wants the yard. Less flexible than Suns/Brotherhood, but the exile clause is why it’s still a staple. - Cry of the Carnarium (`{1}{B}{B}`) — -2/-2 plus exile-from-battlefield-this-turn / die-to-exile. Murders tokens and low-toughness tribal, and hates graveyard strategies in the same card. - Pyroclasm (`{1}{R}`) — Cheapest real wipe at 2, 2 to each creature. Pure and efficient vs 1-toughness swarms; no extra mode, so pair it with flex pieces above rather than running it alone if “dead draw” is your worry. - Kozilek's Return (`{2}{R}`) — Instant-speed 2 to each creature, plus a graveyard mode for a bigger wipe later. Instant timing is huge vs combat/tribal pumps; the second use is the “not just a wipe” angle. - Suffocating Fumes (`{2}{B}`) — Instant -1/-1 to opponents’ creatures and cycling `{2}`. One-sided-ish, cheap cycle, perfect vs tokens and early go-wide.
Anger of the Gods
Collected Company
Cry of the Carnarium
Pyroclasm
Kozilek's Return
Suffocating Fumes
Honorable / situational flex pieces
- The Elder Dragon War — Read-ahead saga: chapter I is a 2-damage wipe + face damage; II rummages; III makes a 4/4 flyer. Always does *something* after you start it. - Scavenger Regent // Exude Toxin — Body with ward, or omen for an X -X/-X (non-Dragons). Cast the dragon when you don’t need the wipe. - Night Clubber — ETB -1/-1 to opponents’ creatures; Blitz for a temporary body + draw. Partial wipe that is still a creature. - Ritual of Soot / Shadows' Verdict — MV-based clears aimed at low-curve aggro; Verdict also hits the yard. Less flexible, very good from the sideboard. - Ratchet Bomb / Blast Zone — Colorless, scalable by mana value. Slow to charge, but never color-locked and can hit noncreatures.
The Elder Dragon War
Scavenger Regent // Exude Toxin
Night Clubber
Ritual of Soot
Shadows' Verdict
Ratchet Bomb
Blast Zone
Quick pick guide
- Maindeck “always castable” package: Brotherhood's End, Sweltering Suns, Gruesome Realization, Extinction Event - Max hate vs early tribal + recursion: Anger of the Gods, Cry of the Carnarium, Pyroclasm / Kozilek's Return - Want a permanent that isn’t a dead sorcery: The Elder Dragon War, Scavenger Regent, Night Clubber
Brotherhood's End
Sweltering Suns
Gruesome Realization
Extinction Event
Anger of the Gods
Cry of the Carnarium
Pyroclasm
Kozilek's Return
If you tell me the rest of the deck (Rakdos midrange, mono-red, sacrifice, control, etc.), I can narrow this to a concrete 2–4 suite and copy counts.