Best Pioneer board wipes in red and/or black
You’re asking for interaction pieces, not a full deck — so here’s a short ranked list of Pioneer-legal (R) Red/(B) Black sweepers that hit early tribal/aggro and still do something when the board is empty or you don’t want to wipe yourself.
Tier 1 — best “never dead” / flexible packages
- Brotherhood's End (`{1}{R}{R}`) — Choose 3 to each creature and planeswalker or destroy all artifacts with mana value 3 or less. Best pure modal sweeper in red for Pioneer: clears go-wide boards *and* has a real mode vs The One Ring, treasure piles, and cheap mana rocks.
- Extinction Event (`{3}{B}`) — Odd/even exile wipe. Often one-sided if your curve is mostly the other parity; exile stops recursion. Slightly higher CMC, but the “choose the side that hurts them” flexibility is exactly what you asked for.
- Sweltering Suns (`{1}{R}{R}`) — 3 to each creature plus cycling `{3}`. If you don’t need the wipe, cycle it. Clean answer to “stuck in hand.”
- Gruesome Realization (`{1}{B}{B}`) — Modal: draw two (pay 2) or opponents’ creatures get -1/-1. Partial wipe vs tokens/X/1s *or* pure card advantage. Excellent midrange flex slot.
- Slagstorm (`{1}{R}{R}`) — 3 to each creature or 3 to each player. When you don’t need the board clear, it becomes reach/finisher. Great “burn that can also wipe.”
Tier 2 — low cost, strong vs early aggro/tribal
- Anger of the Gods (`{1}{R}{R}`) — 3 and exile instead of dying. The gold standard vs Collected Company lines, phoenixes, and anything that wants the yard. Less flexible than Suns/Brotherhood, but the exile clause is why it’s still a staple.
- Cry of the Carnarium (`{1}{B}{B}`) — -2/-2 plus exile-from-battlefield-this-turn / die-to-exile. Murders tokens and low-toughness tribal, and hates graveyard strategies in the same card.
- Pyroclasm (`{1}{R}`) — Cheapest real wipe at 2, 2 to each creature. Pure and efficient vs 1-toughness swarms; no extra mode, so pair it with flex pieces above rather than running it alone if “dead draw” is your worry.
- Kozilek's Return (`{2}{R}`) — Instant-speed 2 to each creature, plus a graveyard mode for a bigger wipe later. Instant timing is huge vs combat/tribal pumps; the second use is the “not just a wipe” angle.
- Suffocating Fumes (`{2}{B}`) — Instant -1/-1 to opponents’ creatures and cycling `{2}`. One-sided-ish, cheap cycle, perfect vs tokens and early go-wide.
Honorable / situational flex pieces
- The Elder Dragon War — Read-ahead saga: chapter I is a 2-damage wipe + face damage; II rummages; III makes a 4/4 flyer. Always does *something* after you start it.
- Scavenger Regent // Exude Toxin — Body with ward, or omen for an X -X/-X (non-Dragons). Cast the dragon when you don’t need the wipe.
- Night Clubber — ETB -1/-1 to opponents’ creatures; Blitz for a temporary body + draw. Partial wipe that is still a creature.
- Ritual of Soot / Shadows' Verdict — MV-based clears aimed at low-curve aggro; Verdict also hits the yard. Less flexible, very good from the sideboard.
- Ratchet Bomb / Blast Zone — Colorless, scalable by mana value. Slow to charge, but never color-locked and can hit noncreatures.
- Maindeck “always castable” package: Brotherhood's End, Sweltering Suns, Gruesome Realization, Extinction Event
- Max hate vs early tribal + recursion: Anger of the Gods, Cry of the Carnarium, Pyroclasm / Kozilek's Return
- Want a permanent that isn’t a dead sorcery: The Elder Dragon War, Scavenger Regent, Night Clubber
If you tell me the rest of the deck (Rakdos midrange, mono-red, sacrifice, control, etc.), I can narrow this to a concrete 2–4 suite and copy counts.